Consensus Project Home


Sources of the Problem

Learn More

Consult the Report of the President’'s New Freedom Commission on Mental Health for a comprehensive account of the status, and many failings, of mental health care in the United States. For more on the relationship between deinstitutionalization and the involvement of people with mental illness in the criminal justice system, advocates should review "The Impact of State Mental Hospital Deinstitutionalization on United States' Prison Populations 1968-78."

Reasons for the high numbers of people with mental illness who are involved in the criminal justice system are complex and interrelated. While some suggest that the problem is the direct result of deinstitutionalization, the research does not support this simplistic explanation. There is no doubt that the shift away from institutional mental health care, and the associated underfunding of community-based mental health services, is at the heart of the problem, but there is little evidence that those formerly housed in institutions have been shifted to jails and prisonsix

Other sources of the problem include the lack of affordable housing, discrimination based on stereotypes associating mental illness with violence, crackdowns on “public nuisance” crimes, and tough prosecution of drug offenses.xi These forces, together with the inability of the criminal justice and mental health systems to recognize and address the problem, all contribute to this disturbing trend.




Proceed to: "Solutions to the Problem"